Topic guides

Quality management for AAA: ISQM 1, ISQM 2 and ISA 220

Quality management · 6 min read

A quality management question usually hands you a file note full of problems: an engagement partner who never reviewed the going concern work, a trainee on a complex group, a deadline moved forward by two weeks. Scoring means naming the standard each problem breaches, explaining why it matters to this audit, and saying what the firm should do. The line I come back to most on this topic is one every auditor learns early: not documented, not performed.

Two levels: the firm and the engagement

StandardLevelWhat it requires
ISQM 1The firmA system of quality management built on quality objectives, the risks to them, and responses to those risks
ISQM 2The firm, for chosen engagementsEngagement quality reviews: who can do them and what they cover
ISA 220 (Revised)The single auditThe engagement partner's responsibility for managing and achieving quality on that audit

Keep the levels apart in your answer. A trainee left unsupervised on one audit is an ISA 220 problem. A firm that never checks whether its partners supervise is an ISQM 1 problem.

ISQM 1: the eight components

ComponentWhat a weakness looks like
The firm's risk assessment processQuality objectives set once and never revisited
Governance and leadershipPartner bonuses driven by fee income alone
Relevant ethical requirementsNo annual independence confirmations collected
Acceptance and continuanceA client kept on despite unpaid fees and a breakdown of trust
Engagement performanceNo review of the riskiest areas before signing
ResourcesStaff without industry experience put on a specialist audit
Information and communicationInspection findings never shared with audit teams
Monitoring and remediationDeficiencies found, root causes never identified

ISQM 1 asks for responses designed for the firm's own risks. Writing "the firm should improve its controls" earns little. "The firm should require a second partner review of going concern work on every audit where a covenant is tested within 12 months" earns credit.

ISQM 2: engagement quality reviews

ISQM 1 requires an engagement quality review for:

  • audits of listed (publicly traded) entities
  • audits where law or regulation requires one
  • any engagement where the firm decides a review is the right response to a quality risk

The reviewer must be competent, must be objective, and must not have been the engagement partner on that audit in the previous two years. The review must be finished before the auditor's report is dated.

ISA 220 (Revised): the engagement partner

The engagement partner is responsible for quality on the audit and must be involved enough to show it. The standard expects:

  • direction and supervision that suit the team's experience
  • timely review of the work, especially significant judgements
  • a stand-back before the report is signed: is the partner satisfied that their involvement was sufficient and appropriate throughout the audit?

When a scenario shows a partner who signed without reviewing the riskiest work, say that the partner cannot show sufficient involvement, and say what has to happen before the report is issued.

Reviews and root causes

ReviewWhenPurpose
Hot reviewBefore the report is signedCatch problems on this audit
Cold reviewAfter the report is signedFind patterns across audits
Root cause analysisAfter a deficiency is foundFix the cause rather than the symptom

Technology and quality

ApproachQuality riskResponse
Data analyticsThe extract may be incompleteReconcile record counts and totals to the general ledger before relying on any test
Remote auditingPhysical existence is harder to evidenceAttend counts in person for material inventory, or use live video with the auditor directing the camera
Automated toolsTeams over-rely on outputHave scripts reviewed by someone who did not write them, and document how each exception was cleared

Analytics supports substantive testing. It replaces none of it unless the evidence it produces is sufficient on its own.

Before you submit

  • Each problem is tied to the right standard and the right level.
  • Each problem says why it matters to this audit.
  • Each recommendation is specific to the firm in the scenario.

The framework for audit quality

The IAASB's framework looks at audit quality from five angles. A good answer to a quality question often touches more than one.

ElementWhat it coversA weakness in a scenario
InputsValues, ethics, knowledge, experience and timeA team without industry experience
ProcessThe methodology and how the work is doneNo review of significant judgements
OutputsThe auditor's report and communicationsA report signed before the work was finished
InteractionsContact with management and those charged with governanceFindings never discussed with the audit committee
ContextLaw, regulation, governance and the wider environmentA deadline cut without the scope changing

Common mistakes on quality questions

  • Writing ISQC 1, which ISQM 1 replaced.
  • Treating every problem as a firm-level failure, when it may be one partner on one audit.
  • Recommending "more training" or "a bigger sample" without tying it to the specific failure in the scenario.
  • Forgetting documentation. Under ISA 230, work that is not documented is treated as not performed.

Test yourself

1. Which standard governs quality on a single audit engagement?ISQM 1 · ISQM 2 · ISA 220 (Revised) · ISA 230Show answer

Answer: ISA 220 (Revised). ISQM 1 sets the firm's system; ISQM 2 covers engagement quality reviews.

2. How long must a former engagement partner wait before acting as engagement quality reviewer on the same audit?No wait · One year · Two years · Five yearsShow answer

Answer: Two years.

3. When must the engagement quality review be finished?Before the auditor's report is dated · Within a month of signing · At the next cold review · Before the planning meetingShow answer

Answer: Before the auditor's report is dated.

4. Which ISQM 1 component covers a firm where partner bonuses depend on fee income alone?Resources · Governance and leadership · Monitoring and remediation · Engagement performanceShow answer

Answer: Governance and leadership. Rewarding fees over quality sets the wrong tone.

5. Which review takes place after the auditor's report is signed, to find patterns across audits?Hot review · Cold review · Engagement quality review · Stand-backShow answer

Answer: Cold review.


Current against the December 2026 examinable documents list, checked 20 November 2026.

All free resources