Answer technique

Professional skills in five days: a planning case

Professional skills · 8 min read

Of the paper's 100, 20 go to professional skills: communication, analysis and evaluation, professional scepticism and judgement, and commercial acumen. They are not a separate answer. They come from how you write the technical one. This is a five-day practice set on one invented client, about 15 minutes a day. Try each task before you read my answer.

The client: Halvard Engineering Co

Halvard Engineering Co is a family-owned electronics manufacturer planning a stock exchange listing next year. You are planning the audit for the year ended 31 December 20X5.

  • Revenue is up 20%, after expansion into overseas markets and a late-December sales push. Several large orders were dispatched on 31 December.
  • Trade receivables are up 30%. Management reversed a £640,000 doubtful debt provision, citing the credit quality of new overseas customers.
  • Profit before tax sits just above a debt covenant threshold. Management is targeting a 15% net margin, against 10% last year.
  • A new inventory system went live mid-year in a hurry. Early counts did not match the system records. Year-end inventory is £15m, well up on last year, partly from a product line launched in November.
  • £4m of development costs for that product line were capitalised, and an older factory was revalued, with a £2.5m surplus in other comprehensive income.
  • In May, Halvard bought a German competitor, giving rise to £5m of goodwill. A local firm will audit the subsidiary.
  • The finance director is the chief executive's son. The finance director's wife owns a major supplier.
  • The audit partner has led the audit for eight years. The firm also advised on the new inventory system.
  • A customer has filed an injury claim over a defective product. Management has disclosed a contingent liability and recognised no provision.
  • A one-off gain on selling an unused property is included in operating income.

Day 1: communication

Task. Write three points for the partner on the planning issues raised by the revenue and receivables facts. Use a heading for each.

Self-check. Is there a heading for each point? Is there one idea per point? Would the partner know why each point matters without reading the scenario again?

My answer.

  • Revenue cut-off. Large orders dispatched on 31 December may have been recorded before control passed to the customer, overstating 20X5 revenue.
  • Receivables valuation. Receivables are up 30%, and the £640,000 provision was released for customers with no payment history, so receivables may be overstated.
  • Management bias. The listing and the covenant both reward higher profit, so every judgement in these two areas needs more challenge than usual.

Day 2: analysis and evaluation

Task. Rank revenue and receivables, inventory and the legal claim from most to least significant. Give a reason for each position.

Self-check. Did you use impact, likelihood and incentive? Did you compare the risks with each other rather than describe each one alone?

My answer.

  1. Revenue and receivables. The 31 December dispatches and the £640,000 release both move profit in the direction management wants, at a point where the covenant and the listing reward it. Material, likely, and backed by a clear incentive.
  2. Inventory. £15m is material on any measure, and the count differences show the new system has not been reliable. The new product line has no sales history to support its valuation.
  3. The legal claim. It could be material, but the size of the claim is not yet known, and the issue is one of classification and disclosure. It ranks third, with the caveat that it moves up if the claim value turns out large.

Day 3: professional scepticism and judgement

Task. Pick three of management's positions and challenge each one. A question on its own is uncertainty. A challenge names the claim, gives the evidence against it and says what the auditor will do.

Self-check. Does each challenge use a fact from the scenario? Does each end in an action?

My answer.

  • The provision release. Management says the new customers are creditworthy, but they have no payment history with Halvard, and the release lifts profit towards the covenant. I would inspect January and February receipts from those customers and obtain external credit ratings before accepting the release.
  • The margin target. A jump from 10% to 15% in one year, alongside signs that expenses were deferred, suggests costs may be sitting in the wrong period. I would inspect supplier invoices received in January and February for services delivered before the year end, and test the accruals listing against them.
  • The supplier owned by the finance director's wife. Management says past disclosure was enough, but the transactions are significant and the relationship is close. I would compare prices on a sample of this supplier's invoices with quotes from other suppliers, and inspect board minutes for approval of the contract.

Day 4: commercial acumen

Task. For each of four issues, say what it means for investors, the bank or the business itself.

Self-check. Did you name a stakeholder for each issue? Did you stay inside the auditor's role, without telling management how to run the company?

My answer.

  • Revenue and receivables, for investors. If aggressive recognition comes out after the listing, the restatement would land on new shareholders who priced the shares on 20X5 profit.
  • Inventory, for the bank. An overstated £15m that is later written down would reduce profit, and could take the company through the covenant it is close to now.
  • Related parties, for the business. Weak disclosure of a supplier owned by a director's family would be raised in listing due diligence and could delay the timetable.
  • The legal claim, for everyone. A provision recognised after the listing would hit profit and raise questions about what management knew.

Day 5: all four together

Task. Write a briefing note of six to eight points for the partner. Rank the risks, challenge at least two of management's positions, and give the commercial consequence of each risk.

My answer.

To: Audit engagement partner
Subject: Halvard Engineering Co, planning for the year ended 31 December 20X5

Most significant: revenue and receivables. The 31 December dispatches and the £640,000 provision release both increase profit just above the covenant and ahead of the listing. Management's view that the new customers are creditworthy has no payment history behind it. We will test cut-off on dispatches around the year end and inspect receipts after it before accepting the release.

Second: inventory of £15m. The new system produced count differences, and the November product line has no sales history. We will attend the count and test the new line's net realisable value against early 20X6 prices. An overstatement here would threaten the covenant.

Third: the supplier owned by the finance director's wife. The transactions are significant and past disclosure was thin. We will test pricing against other suppliers. This disclosure will be read closely in listing due diligence.

Ethics. Eight years as partner and the firm's work on the inventory system create familiarity and self-review threats. With a listing next year Halvard will become a public interest entity, so I recommend we plan the partner's rotation now. Because the firm advised on the inventory system, its controls should be tested by staff who had no part in that advice.

Also on the plan: the legal claim, the goodwill on the German acquisition and our instructions to the component auditor, the factory revaluation, and the classification of the property gain.

That note picks up all four skills without naming any of them. That is how it works in the exam too.

Test yourself

1. In which section of the paper is communication assessed?Section A only · Section B only · Both · NeitherShow answer

Answer: Section A only. Section B questions assess at least two of the other three skills.

2. Which of these is a sceptical point that scores?"Why was the provision released?" · "The provision release should be questioned." · "The £640,000 release has no payment history behind it and lifts profit towards the covenant, so I would inspect receipts after the year end before accepting it." · "Management may be biased."Show answer

Answer: The third. It names the claim, gives the evidence against it and ends in an action.

3. What makes a ranking of risks earn credit?Listing every risk · A reason for each position, using size, likelihood and incentive · Putting the largest figure first · Numbering the risksShow answer

Answer: A reason for each position. The ranking is a judgement, and the reason is what shows it.

4. Where does commercial acumen stop?At the auditor's role: link consequences to stakeholders without telling management how to run the business · It has no limit · At the year end · At materialityShow answer

Answer: At the auditor's role. Advising management how to run the business earns nothing.

5. Halvard will list next year. What does that change for the ethics position?Nothing · It becomes a public interest entity, so partner tenure and non-audit services need attention now · Only the fee rules change · The audit is no longer neededShow answer

Answer: It becomes a public interest entity, so partner tenure and non-audit services need attention now.


Current against the December 2026 examinable documents list, checked 20 November 2026.

All free resources