Answer technique

Weak, middle and strong: seven AAA answers side by side

Answer technique · 11 min read

Write your own answer to each requirement first. Then score yourself against the three versions below.

The scale is the one I use when I go through a student's practice answer. A fully developed point scores 2. A point that names the issue but stops scores 1 at most. A point that could sit in any answer to any question scores 0. Of the paper's 100, 20 go to professional skills, and every strong answer below picks some of those up as it goes.

When I go through a student's practice answer, I ask one question of every point: could someone act on it tomorrow from the wording alone?

The client in sections 1 to 3 is invented. Corrin Pharmaceuticals has a 31 December year end and performance materiality of $310,000.

1. Audit risk at planning: Corrin Pharmaceuticals

Requirement: evaluate the risks of material misstatement and recommend responses.

Risk A: development costs of $18.4 million

Weak · 0 of 2

Development costs may be misstated.

No client fact, no size, no direction, no response. It fits every pharmaceutical company that has ever existed.

Middle · 1 of 2

Corrin has capitalised development costs, and some of this may be research, which cannot be capitalised.

The direction is now there. The size and the auditor's response are still missing.

Strong · 2 of 2, using IRER

Identify: Corrin has capitalised $18.4m of development costs across three drugs, one of which is subject to a patent dispute.
Risk: intangible assets overstated (existence and valuation), if research-phase costs were capitalised or the disputed drug fails the recoverability test in IAS 38.
Explain: $18.4m is 59 times performance materiality, so even a partial error is material to the statement of financial position and to profit.
Response: inspect the stage-gate approval for each drug to confirm the date technical feasibility was established, and agree a sample of capitalised payroll and laboratory invoices to dates after that point.

Risk B: $4.2 million of late revenue on sale-or-return

Weak

Revenue might be wrong around year end.

Strong

Identify: Corrin booked $4.2m on its new veterinary line in November and December, on sale-or-return terms.
Risk: revenue overstated (occurrence and cut-off). Under IFRS 15, revenue is limited to the amount not expected to reverse when returns are likely.
Explain: $4.2m is 13.5 times performance materiality.
Response: inspect returns recorded in January and February against December dispatches, and inspect the distributor contracts for the return window.

2. Procedures: customer deposits received in advance

Requirement: recommend procedures to obtain evidence over the liability for customer deposits.

Weak · scores 0

Check the deposits are recorded correctly.

"Check" is not a procedure. There is no source and no assertion.

Middle

Review contracts, make sure deposits are in deferred income, recalculate the balance.

There are some verbs here, but nobody could run these from the wording.

Strong · SAP (source, action, purpose)

  1. Inspect the sales contract register for contracts with advance-payment clauses, and agree each one to the deposits ledger, to test completeness of the liability.
  2. Agree deposits received in the last two weeks of December from the bank statement to the deferred income account, to confirm they were not credited to revenue (cut-off).
  3. Recalculate the deferred balance for a sample of contracts as deposit received less the value of goods delivered by 31 December, to test valuation.
  4. Inspect January delivery notes for the same sample to confirm the goods were delivered after the year end.

Each line names a document, an action a junior could take and the assertion it tests. That is the whole of SAP.

3. Ethics: an audit client that has not paid

Requirement: evaluate the ethical issues and recommend actions.

Issue A: last year's fee still unpaid

Weak

Self-interest threat. Apply safeguards.

These are labels only. The significance of the threat and the actual safeguard are both missing.

Strong · threat, then significance, then safeguard

Threat: Corrin still owes $96,000 of last year's audit fee. Overdue fees create a self-interest threat, because the firm has a stake in the client staying solvent and keeping it happy.
Significance: the arrears are 80% of this year's fee and have been outstanding for 11 months. The longer a fee stays unpaid, the closer it gets to a loan to the client, which the IESBA Code prohibits.
Safeguard: require payment before this year's auditor's report is signed. Have a partner who is not on the engagement review the work. If the fee is still unpaid, the firm should consider resigning.

Issue B: hospitality from the finance director

Weak

The audit team should not accept gifts.

Strong

The finance director has offered the audit senior two hospitality-box seats at a cup final, worth about $3,000. That is a self-interest and familiarity threat. The IESBA Code lets an audit team member accept gifts and hospitality from an audit client only when they are trivial and inconsequential, and $3,000 is neither. No safeguard reduces the threat to an acceptable level, so the senior declines and the engagement partner records the offer.

4. Reporting: going concern disclosure left out

Requirement: evaluate the effect on the auditor's report if management will not disclose a material uncertainty over going concern.

Weak

Adverse opinion because of going concern.

This jumps to an opinion without any reasoning about material or pervasive.

Strong

A material uncertainty exists: the company cannot meet a $2.6m loan repayment due in April without new finance, and none is agreed. Leaving it out of the notes makes the financial statements materially misstated. If the omission is material but not pervasive, the opinion is qualified ("except for"), with a basis for qualified opinion paragraph explaining what is missing. If the omission is so fundamental that the statements as a whole mislead, the opinion is adverse. Under ISA 570 (Revised 2024), the auditor's report also carries a going concern section setting out the auditor's conclusions.

Most weak answers miss the step in the middle: decide material or pervasive first, and the opinion follows from that.

5. Money laundering: "security payments" to officials

Requirement: discuss the implications and the actions the auditor should take.

Weak

This is illegal. Resign.

Resigning on the spot skips every duty the auditor actually has.

Strong

Issue: payments of $45,000 to port officials, recorded as "security", may be bribes. The proceeds of crime they generate are criminal property, so this is a money laundering matter as well as non-compliance with laws and regulations.
Financial statements: the payments may be misclassified, and fines or penalties may need a provision or a contingent liability disclosure under IAS 37.
Actions: obtain the facts and documents behind each payment. Report internally to the firm's money laundering reporting officer, who decides whether to make an external report. Discuss the non-compliance with those charged with governance, but never disclose that a report has been made, because that is tipping off and is itself an offence. Consider the effect on the opinion if the matter is not properly reflected.

6. Group audit: a component audited by another firm

Requirement: explain the group auditor's responsibilities and recommend actions.

Weak

Ask the other auditor for their report and rely on it if it is clean.

Under ISA 600 (Revised), the group auditor keeps responsibility for the group opinion and cannot hand it off by asking for a report.

Strong

  1. Evaluate the component auditor's competence, resources and compliance with ethical requirements, including independence, before deciding how far to involve them.
  2. Set component performance materiality below group performance materiality, to allow for aggregation risk, and communicate it in writing with the risks the component auditor must address.
  3. Specify what the component auditor reports back and when, including any misstatements found and any instances of non-compliance.
  4. Inspect the component auditor's documentation for the significant risks, with intra-group balances and goodwill impairment first, and discuss significant findings before the group opinion is signed.

7. Data analytics: challenges and quality controls

Requirement: discuss the challenges of using data analytics on revenue and recommend quality controls.

Weak

Analytics is faster and covers 100% of transactions.

These are benefits, and the requirement asked for challenges. The March/June 2024 report recorded exactly this mistake.

Strong

Challenges: the data extract may not be complete, so reconcile the extract to the general ledger before any test relies on it. A broad script can flag thousands of exceptions, and following them up costs more time than a sample would have. Client data leaving its systems raises confidentiality obligations. And a team can treat a clean run as evidence in itself when it is only a pointer to where to look.
Controls: reconcile record counts and totals to the ledger for every extract. Version-control each script, and have it reviewed by someone who did not write it, consistent with the firm's quality management system under ISQM 1 and ISA 220 (Revised). Agree secure transfer and access logs with the client in the engagement letter. Document how each exception was resolved and what evidence closed it.

The pattern across all seven

Point typeScores 0Scores 1Scores 2
Risk"Revenue risk"Names the client or the standardClient fact, figure, direction and response
Procedure"Check invoices"An action with a document or a purposeSource, action and purpose
Ethics"Threat exists"Threat and safeguardThreat, significance on the facts, specific safeguard
Reporting"Qualify"Names a modificationMaterial or pervasive, then the opinion, then the basis paragraph

Before your next timed attempt, read one of your old answers against the right-hand column. In my experience the first gap students find is the figure.

Test yourself

1. A risk point names the client and the balance but gives no figure and no response. On the scale used here, what does it score?0 · 1 at most · 2 · It depends on the verbShow answer

Answer: 1 at most. Naming the issue earns something; without the size against materiality and a response, it stops short of a developed point.

2. Which of these is a procedure a junior could carry out from the wording alone?Check the deposits · Review the contracts · Agree December receipts on the bank statement to the deferred income account · Verify the liabilityShow answer

Answer: Agree December receipts on the bank statement to the deferred income account. It names the source, the action and, by implication, the cut-off it tests. The other three are verbs with nothing attached.

3. Management will not disclose a material going concern uncertainty, and the omission is material but not pervasive. What opinion follows?Unmodified with a going concern section · Qualified, except for · Adverse · DisclaimerShow answer

Answer: Qualified, except for. Leaving out a required disclosure is a misstatement. Material but not pervasive gives a qualified opinion.

4. The audit team suspects a client's payments are bribes and the money laundering reporting officer makes a report. What must the team never do?Discuss the payments with the audit committee · Tell the client a report has been made · Consider the effect on the opinion · Obtain documents for each paymentShow answer

Answer: Tell the client a report has been made. That is tipping off, a criminal offence. Discussing the non-compliance itself with those charged with governance is allowed.

5. The requirement asks for the challenges of using data analytics. A candidate writes that analytics covers 100% of transactions. Why does that score nothing?It is factually wrong · It is a benefit, and the requirement asked for challenges · It needs a figure · It needs an ISA referenceShow answer

Answer: It is a benefit, and the requirement asked for challenges. The March/June 2024 report recorded exactly this mistake.


Current against the December 2026 examinable documents list, checked 20 November 2026.

All free resources