Topic guides
Audit risk at planning: how to write a risk that scores
Section A opens at the planning stage, so most papers ask you to evaluate the risks of material misstatement and usually to rank them. This page is the structure I teach for every risk point, with worked examples on an invented client.
The structure: IRER
| Step | What you write |
|---|---|
| Identify | The scenario fact, with the name and the figure |
| Risk | The balance, the direction (over or under) and the assertion |
| Explain | The size against materiality and why it matters |
| Response | A specific procedure, only if the requirement asks for responses |
When the verb is evaluate, discuss or comment, the last step becomes a judgement instead of a response.
The framework is a thinking tool. If you fill in four boxes without reading what the requirement asks, the structure will not save the answer.
The client
Harrowgate Foods Co makes chilled ready meals. The year end is 30 September, profit before tax is $7.4 million and performance materiality is $260,000. The finance director's bonus is paid on reported profit, and the bank's interest cover covenant is tested at the year end.
Five worked risks
Inventory: short shelf life
Identify: Harrowgate holds $2.3m of finished goods with a use-by window of 21 days, and a supermarket customer cancelled a $900,000 order in September.
Risk: inventory overstated (valuation), because goods that cannot be sold before their use-by date are worth less than cost under IAS 2.
Explain: the cancelled order alone is 3.5 times performance materiality.
Response: inspect October sales invoices and write-off records for the cancelled product lines, and compare realised prices to cost.
Revenue: volume rebates
Identify: a new contract gives the largest customer a 4% retrospective rebate once annual purchases pass $20m. Purchases reached $19.6m by the year end, and no accrual was made.
Risk: revenue overstated and liabilities understated (accuracy and completeness), because IFRS 15 requires expected rebates to reduce revenue as sales are made.
Explain: a 4% rebate on $19.6m is $784,000, three times performance materiality, and it sits on the profit figure the bonus depends on.
Response: inspect the contract terms and October sales to the customer to judge whether the threshold was likely to be passed, and recalculate the accrual.
Property, plant and equipment: a new line
Identify: a $6.1m production line came into use in July. Installation staff costs of $480,000 were capitalised.
Risk: property, plant and equipment overstated (valuation), if costs that are not directly attributable, such as training, were included under IAS 16.
Explain: $480,000 is almost twice performance materiality.
Response: agree a sample of capitalised staff costs to timesheets coded to the installation project and dated before the line came into use.
Provisions: a product recall
Identify: in August, Harrowgate recalled one product after a contamination report. Management has disclosed a contingent liability and recognised no provision.
Risk: provisions understated (completeness), because a recall already announced is a present obligation from a past event under IAS 37.
Explain: the retailer's claim letter seeks $1.1m, more than four times performance materiality.
Response: inspect correspondence with the retailer and the company's lawyers, and recalculate the provision from the claim and the recall costs incurred since the year end.
Management override
Identify: profit before tax is $7.4m against a bonus target of $7.2m, and interest cover is 3.1 times against a covenant minimum of 3.0.
Risk: profit overstated through journals or estimates (pervasive).
Explain: ISA 240 (Revised) treats management override as a risk on every audit. Here the incentive is measurable: a swing of around $200,000 crosses both lines.
Response: inspect journals posted after the year end and by senior staff, and compare this year's estimates with how last year's estimates turned out.
Ranking the risks
Rank the risks of material misstatement when the partner's email asks you to. The March/June 2026 report records candidates ranking business risks that nobody asked them to rank, and gaining nothing for it.
My ranking for Harrowgate: the rebate accrual first ($784,000, sitting directly on the bonus and covenant figures), then the recall provision, then inventory. Say why in one sentence. The ranking is a judgement, and the reason is what shows it.
Business risk and risk of misstatement
A business risk is what could harm Harrowgate: losing the supermarket contract. The matching risk of misstatement is what could be wrong in the accounts because of it: inventory for that contract carried above net realisable value. Write the risk the requirement asks for, and if both are asked for, keep them in separate sections.
Before you submit
- Every risk has a name and a figure from the scenario.
- Every risk states the balance, the direction and the assertion.
- Every risk is measured against materiality.
- Responses appear only if the requirement asks for them.
- The ranking has a reason.
Risk themes that keep coming up
Each line pairs a common scenario fact with the risk it creates and a response. Use it to spot risks quickly, then develop each one with IRER.
| Scenario fact | Risk and assertion | Typical response |
|---|---|---|
| Customer pays in advance, such as annual memberships | Revenue overstated, cut-off | Recalculate the deferred income balance from contract start dates |
| Goods shipped before the year end with returns after it | Revenue overstated, occurrence | Inspect returns after the year end against December dispatches |
| Software sold with support bundled in | Revenue misallocated between obligations, accuracy | Inspect contracts and recalculate the allocation under IFRS 15 |
| Inventory turnover slowing sharply | Inventory overstated, valuation | Compare cost with selling prices after the year end |
| Development costs capitalised for an early-stage project | Intangibles overstated, valuation | Inspect feasibility evidence against the IAS 38 criteria |
| An acquired subsidiary making losses | Goodwill overstated, valuation | Recalculate management's impairment test and challenge the growth rate |
| A revaluation in the year | Deferred tax understated, completeness | Recalculate deferred tax on the surplus under IAS 12 |
| A legal claim disclosed but not provided | Provisions understated, completeness | Inspect lawyers' correspondence and the claim value |
| A bonus tied to profit | Profit overstated, all assertions | Inspect late and unusual journals |
| Loans with covenants close to breach | Going concern basis and disclosure | Recalculate each covenant at each future test date |
Professional skills in a risk answer
| Skill | How it shows in a risk answer |
|---|---|
| Communication | Headed sections, one risk per paragraph, written for the partner |
| Analysis and evaluation | Every risk sized against materiality, and a reasoned ranking |
| Professional scepticism and judgement | Management's position set against the evidence that contradicts it |
| Commercial acumen | The consequence for the bank, investors or the business, within the auditor's role |
Test yourself
1. Harrowgate's largest customer earns a 4% rebate once purchases pass $20m. Purchases reached $19.6m and no accrual was made. Which way is revenue misstated?Understated · Overstated · Not misstated · Cannot tellShow answer
Answer: Overstated. IFRS 15 requires expected rebates to reduce revenue as sales are made.
2. Which step of IRER is replaced by a judgement when the verb is evaluate?Identify · Risk · Explain · ResponseShow answer
Answer: Response. When the requirement asks for evaluation, the point closes with a justified judgement.
3. A recall was announced in August and the retailer has claimed $1.1m. Management disclosed a contingent liability. What is the risk?Provisions overstated · Provisions understated · Revenue overstated · NoneShow answer
Answer: Provisions understated. An announced recall is a present obligation from a past event under IAS 37.
4. Under ISA 240 (Revised), which risk is treated as present on every audit?Inventory obsolescence · Management override of controls · Going concern · Related party transactionsShow answer
Answer: Management override of controls.
5. A requirement asks for risks of material misstatement only. Should you include responses?Yes, always · Only if the requirement asks for them · Only for the top risk · NeverShow answer
Answer: Only if the requirement asks for them. The March/June 2026 report recorded no credit for responses that were not requested.
Current against the December 2026 examinable documents list, checked 20 November 2026.